Best Electric Sandwich Maker Reviews | Expert opinion

Are you thinking of buying an electric sandwich maker? Don’t understand which brand to choose? Don’t worry. Because I have come with the best electric sandwich maker review for you.

Sandwiches are one of the easy to-go items. When you are in a hurry and don’t have enough time to make several items, a sandwich is a life-saver option. Sandwich is a trendy food item because of its delicious taste, food value, and facile making process. A sandwich maker can make your job easier. But people sometimes become confused about which brand of the sandwich maker to buy. Because multiple brands provide electric sandwich makers with various features.

I’ve compiled some of the best electric sandwich makers below. Besides, I will let you know the answers to some FAQs. So, let’s start.

Why Need A Sandwich Maker?

There are various benefits that an excellent electric sandwich maker can offer. I have mentioned some of the reasons below:

• Healthy Breakfast: Home-made sandwiches are always hygienic and more nutritious than those of store-bought. You can add or minimize food value as per your choice.
• Time-efficient: When you are in a hurry, a sandwich maker can make your meal. So, you can utilize this time on another task.
• Facile usage: These electric sandwich makers are straightforward to use. Just pre-heat the item, put in the ingredients, and wait for the food.
• Effortless Cleanup: Most modern electric sandwich makers offer non-stick plates that are super easy to clean. Just wipe out the plate to clean.

Our Top picks

• Best Overall: Cuisinart WM-SW2N Sandwich Maker– This sandwich maker offers indicator lights, non-stick plates, equal heat distribution to provide you with more comfort.
• Best Budget: Dash DPM100GBRD06 Compact Panini Press + Electric Sandwich Maker– A handy kitchen appliance that one can find at a low price.
• Best Versatile: Cuisinart GR-4NP1 Sandwich Maker– One will get five cooking options in this versatile sandwich maker.
• Best Indoor sandwich maker: Hamilton Beach 25410 Panini Press + Electric Sandwich Maker– This Electric Sandwich Maker will make restaurant-quality sandwiches for you at home.
• Best for Thick Sandwiches: Hamilton Beach 25460A Electric Panini Press Grill– The floating lid will adjust to the height of the food perfectly.
• Another budget-friendly sandwich maker: Ovente Electric Indoor Sandwich Grill Maker– If you are looking for a 3 in 1 sandwich maker at an affordable price, just grab this one.
• Best for easy cleaning: Hamilton Beach 25430 Electric Sandwich Maker– Just wipe out the non-stick plates and be ready to use next time.
• Best Breakfast Sandwich Press: Chef Buddy 3-in-1 Electric Sandwich Maker– One can make various breakfast items in the morning within the shortest time with this one.
• Best for Large Serving: Chefman RJ02-180 Electric Panini Press Grill and Gourmet Sandwich Maker– The grill can be opened flat to accommodate more food.
• Best Portable: Gotham Steel 2108 sandwich maker– The sandwich maker offers portability to save space.

Best Electric Sandwich Maker Review

Here’s my candid review of the best Electric Sandwich Maker and why I think they’re an excellent pick for you. Moreover, you will get to know the features, pros, and cons to attain a comprehensive overview!

Cuisinart WM-SW2N Sandwich Maker

If you are a sandwich lover, then you will love this non-stick grill sandwich maker. From outlook to function, everything will fascinate you. The Cuisinart WM-SW2N Sandwich Maker will take your sandwiches to the next level by spreading the heat evenly on both sides. The result is a perfect browned grill sandwich. Moreover, you don’t have to stand beside the sandwich maker. The green light will turn on when your sandwiches are ready to serve. The non-stick plates are also hygienic since they are BPA-free.

Product Specifications:

• Item Dimensions: 10.1 x 9.7 x 5.3 inches
• Item Weight: 3.39 pounds
• Material: Stainless steel, Plastic
• Plate Type: Fixed
• Color: Silver

key Features:

• The sandwich maker has ample space for making two sandwiches at a time
• The interior design of the sandwich maker can slice each sandwich in half.
• The red and green indicator lights help to understand the cooking condition
• Equal heat distribution of non-stick plate ensures perfect, crispy sandwiches
• The lock-down lid saves space in the kitchen

Pros:

• Provide a precise cooking surface that is time-efficient
• Compact size is easy to store
• BPA free built-in ensures sound health
• Affordable price

Cons:

• No adjustable temperature system
• The fixed plate is not convenient for deep clean

Dash DPM100GBRD06 Compact Panini Press + Electric Sandwich Maker

If you want your sandwich maker to do something more than a regular one, then this product by Dash is just perfect for you. You can make toast, grilled cheese sandwiches, waffles, and omelets with this pocket sandwich maker. Moreover, the lucrative red color sandwich maker will add beauty to your small kitchen. Again, the pocket sandwich maker is so tiny that it can take up space in your hands. Therefore, it is highly suitable for small kitchens.

Product Specifications:

• Dimensions: 9.17 x 6.46 x 4.88 inches
• Item: Weight: 2 pounds
• Material Type Free: PFOA-free
• Plate type: Dual non-stick plates
• Color: red

key features:

• The small sandwich maker can heat up more quickly than those larger ones.
• It includes red and green light indicators.
• The dual non-stick plates distribute temperature equally
• It has a diagonal indentation feature to divide the sandwiches
• DASH pocket sandwich maker comes with a recipe book and access to the recipe database

Pros:

• It heats the food quickly
• Small size is suitable for small kitchens or college dorm life
• The recipe book is helpful for the new cooker
• It is easy to clean

Cons:

• The cooking surface is small
• The lid is heavier than the base. So, the cover tends to flop down

Cuisinart GR-4NP1 Sandwich Maker

Making different items in the morning becomes a piece of cake with this Cuisinart GR-4NP1 Sandwich Maker. It can function as a contact grill, full grill, full griddle, and half griddle. Besides, you will get removable and reversible non-stick cooking plates, temperature controllable knobs, and light indicators in this sandwich griller.

Product specifications:

• Dimensions: 13.5 x 11.5 x 7.12 inches
• Item Weight: 8 Pounds
• Material: Stainless Steel
• Material Type Free: BPA Free
• Color: Silver

key features:

• The multi-functional sandwich maker can make several items
• It offers five different cooking options with three different knobs
• One can adjust the temperature of each knob
• It includes green and red indicator lights
• The floating cover can easily adjust with the thickness of the food
• The sandwich maker has a reversible grill plate to double up the space

Pros:

• Adjustable temperature control helps to bake various foods perfectly
• Removable, dishwasher-safe, and non-stick plates are super easy to clean
• It is highly convenient for outdoor grilling

Cons:

• The product is heavy and consumes more space
• The upper plate doesn’t become as hot as the bottom
• The side buttons are flimsy

Hamilton Beach 25410 Panini Press + Electric Sandwich Maker

Want restaurant-quality sandwiches and grilled foods at home? Try this Electric Sandwich Maker of Hamilton Beach. The sleek and classic Panini Press will not disappoint you. The floating hinged lid will perfectly cover the food and cook it equally on both sides. Moreover, the bigger cooking surface is convenient for placing large amounts of food. Another specialty of this sandwich grill maker is its cleaning feature. It includes a slide-out drip tray to keep the countertop clean.

Product specifications:

• Dimensions: 13.5 x 13.75 x 5.1 inches
• Item Weight: 5. 8 Pounds
• Material: Nonstick cooking surface
• Material Type Free: BPA Free
• Color: Stainless Steel

key features:

• The 95 square inches of non-stick cooking surface can accommodate three or more sandwiches simultaneously and cook them within10 minutes
• This electric sandwich maker can cook multiple items from burger to steak
• It includes power and pre-heat lights to let you know when the food is ready
• The item comes with a spatula/scraper tool

Pros:

• The bigger cooking surface can contain more foods
• Slide-out drip tray saves the countertop from being messy
• The non-stick plates are simple to clean with a damp cloth
• One can keep it upright to save storage

Cons:

• No heat control setting
• No switch for the on/ off option

Hamilton Beach 25460A Electric Panini Press Grill

As the previous model of Hamilton Beach, it is another versatile electric sandwich maker. One can make quesadillas, bruschettas, Reuben sandwiches, and many other meals with this electric grill. If you want a sandwich with several layers but face difficulties in flipping, this sandwich maker will be your appropriate choice. The non-stick cooking plates firmly grip the food to prevent leakage. Moreover, the spacious cooking surface will reduce your cooking time.

Product specifications:

• Dimensions: 11.61 x 12.64 x 4.53 inches
• Item Weight: 5. 75 Pounds
• Material: Nonstick cooking surface
• Voltage: 120
• Color: Chrome Finish

Key features:

• The stainless steel with sleek design blends with any kitchen decor. 
• The non-stick plates are advantageous for perfect cooking
• The cafe-style floating lid firmly press the sandwiches into it
• It offers light indicators
• Lock panini press lid is suitable for open-faced sandwiches.

Pros:

• The sandwich maker is user-friendly due to its simple light system.
• The sandwich grill offers a versatile cooking facility, from sandwiches to personal pizzas.
• It offers ample space for 2–3 sandwiches at once.
• The non-stick plates are easy to clean.

Cons:

• The non-stick plates are not removable
• No switch for the on/off option
• No temperature control option

Ovente Electric Indoor Sandwich Grill Maker

If you are looking for a 3 in 1 sandwich maker at an affordable price, this one can be the best go-to option. You can make sandwiches, French toast, waffles, sunny-side-up eggs with this sandwich grill maker. The Stainless Steel-built sandwich maker is durable for frequent use. Again, the sandwich maker can make food faster due to its 120V and 750W power.

Product specifications:

• Dimensions: 10.4 x 9.4 x 4.2 inches
• Item Weight: 2.92 pounds
• Material: Stainless Steel, Cast Iron
• Voltage: 120
• Color: Black

Key features:

• The sandwich grill maker features fast-heating elements to cook faster
• It includes light indicators to show cooking condition            
• The non-stick cooking surface provides heat equally
• This sandwich grill maker is heat-resistant to prevent accidents.

Pros:

• The sandwich grill maker offers versatile food preparation
• Heat resistant feature is beneficial to prevent an accident
• Anti-skid feet place the maker standstill
• The plates are detachable for cleaning

Cons:

• The product is not PTFE and PFOA free.
• There is no on and off switch
• The plates are comparatively thin

Hamilton Beach 25430 Electric Sandwich Maker

This time I have come up with another model of a Hamilton Beach sandwich maker. The electric sandwich maker is different from the previous ones to the extent that it has plastic construction. Except for this feature, it has almost similar options to other sandwich makers. If you are a busy parent, this item can get rid of you from many hassles in the morning. You can make sandwiches of any thickness within a few minutes with this lightweight sandwich maker.

Product specifications:

• Dimensions: 10.75 x 11.25 x 4.1 inches
• Item Weight: 3.43 pounds
• Material: Plastic
• Voltage: 110
• Color: Black

key features:

• It provides space for making two sandwiches at once
• The non-stick plates warm-up meals thoroughly
• The item has a compact size
• It includes LED light indicators

Pros:

• It is super easy to clean. Just wipe out the plates with a damp cloth
• It is user-friendly
• The small and lightweight sandwich maker is perfect for a small space
• The indicator light is very responsive

Cons:

• The design of the sandwich maker is not advantageous. There is a gap between plates. One needs to use very narrower things to clean that part.

Chef Buddy 3-in-1 Electric Sandwich Maker         

This is our second 3-in-1 Electric Sandwich Maker on our list. One can make Panini Press, Grill, Waffle, sandwiches in this item quickly. So, this indoor sandwich maker is a suitable year-round option for your whole family. The product comes with changeable plates. So, one can switch the cooking plates that suit the food type. Again, the sturdy stainless steel construction ensures more extended durability.

Product specifications:

• Dimensions: 9.25 x 3.25 x 9 inches
• Item Weight: 5.29 Pounds
• Material: Stainless Steel
• Voltage: 110
• Color: Black

Key features:

• One can make several snacks items in this single versatile sandwich maker
• The 750 Wattage ensures energy-efficient cooking
• Dual heating zones uniformly distributes heat for faster cooking
• The product comes with changeable plates for healthy cooking, grilling, and toasting

Pros:

• Dual heating zones prepare meals faster
• Stainless Steel construction is sturdy
• It is energy efficient
• Affordable price

Cons:

• The product is not dishwasher safe
• The plates are not sturdy

Chefman RJ02-180 Electric Panini Press Grill and Gourmet Sandwich Maker

Have to prepare snacks quickly, but do you have another urgent task? Don’t worry. In this situation, the Chefman RJ02 electric sandwich maker can be your best friend. This grill sandwich maker can prepare foods for two to three people at a time. You can make BBQ, bacon, thicker sandwiches, Panini in this item. The floating hinge ensures a super crispy meal. The larger handle of the sandwich grill maker is solid and easy to use.

Product specifications:

• Dimensions: 13 x 10 x 4 inches
• Item Weight: 4 Pounds
• Material: Stainless Steel
• Voltage: 120
• Wattage: 1000 watts
• Color: Silver with Black

Key features:

• The sandwich maker has a sturdy stainless steel construction
• The larger lay-flat surface can accommodate two sandwiches at once.
• The floating hinge adjusts with any size of sandwiches
• The compact size is ideal for a small place
• The grill can be opened flat to cook more foods

Pros:

• The non-stick plates are easy to use and clean
• The drip tray collects all the grease and keeps the countertop clean
• The tray is dishwasher safe
• The product consumes less space

Cons:

• The plates are not removable
• It offers no adjustable temperature control

Gotham Steel 2108 sandwich maker

Gotham Steel 2108 sandwich maker is the most lightweight sandwich maker on our list. It weighs only 2.72 Pounds. Moreover, it has PTFE and PFOA-free heating plates that ensure good health. Furthermore, you don’t need to add oil or butter to cook food. But your food will still turn out moist on the inside and crispy on the outside. The black-colored, handy sandwich maker is also good-looking and blends well with any kitchen decor.

Product specifications:

• Dimensions: 12 x 12 x 6 inches
• Item Weight: 2.72 Pounds
• Material: Copper
• Material Type Free: PFOA free
• Voltage: 120
• Color: Black

Key features:

• The Sandwich Maker is designed for grilling two sandwiches at once
• The sandwich maker’s indicator lights will inform you of the cooking condition
• The copper construction is durable
• The item is PTFE and PFOA-free
• It offers an easy cleaning feature

Pros:

• The ultra-nonstick cooking plate leaves no bits of food behind
• The sandwich maker is sturdy to use it for a longer time
• PTFE and PFOA-free material ensures safe health
• It is portable and consumes less space

Cons:

• No switch for on and off the sandwich maker
• Though the manufacturer claims the product can cook two sandwiches at once. Some users have complained that the plates are too small even for a normal slice of bread to grill.

How to Choose the Best Sandwich Maker | Buying Guide

One should be very calculative before buying any electric sandwich maker. Here are some factors to look into:

• Dimensions: If you want to prepare meals for your entire family, then choose a larger sandwich maker. So, you can cook more food at once. If you’re going to make meals for a few people, consider a small sandwich maker.
• Power: power is one of the crucial factors in any electrical appliance. If you want to buy an electric sandwich maker for making sandwiches, grill or toast, choose a sandwich maker that uses 700W to 1400W.
• Type of Plates: Electric sandwich maker comes with different cooking plates such as grill plates, waffle plates, sandwich pocket plates. Choose a sandwich maker based on your preferred type of food. For example, grill plates with no pockets are convenient for multilayer grilled cheese sandwiches. If you like sealed and browned sandwiches, go for a product that has sandwich pocket plates.

Another thing is whether the plates are removable or non-removable. If you want to deep clean the cooking plates, go for removable plates. If you are satisfied with wiping out the plates, then fixed plates are also perfect.

• Indicator Lights: Make sure you have indicator lights in your sandwich maker. It will help you to understand if the food is ready to serve or not.

FAQ

My Top Pick

When you read this part, I bet you knew all the information to buy yourself the best electric sandwich maker!

After reviewing the ten best electric sandwich makers, my top pick is Cuisinart GR-4NP1 Sandwich Maker. Because this is the only sandwich maker on the list that offers five different cooking options to provide the users with more versatility. Moreover, I can put more food on the large cooking surface. It is very much time-efficient. It also features a light indication facility, user-friendly usage, and a facile cleaning process.

I have tried to mention the key features of each product with their positive sides and drawbacks. I hope you have found the article helpful.